Scenedoku
Crime-scene logic cases
The Auction House
Marlowe & Voss · opening night of the autumn sale · one of the guests is a forger · Difficulty: Chief 9 · 16×16
Opening night of the autumn sale at the Marlowe & Voss auction house. No sooner had the gavel fallen on lot 40 than a cry rang out from the Strongroom: Vincent, the head auctioneer, lay dead beside the safe. There are fifteen suspects – staff, collectors, dealers, members of the press. There was no time for lot 41.
Rules
- Of the fifteen suspects exactly one is the forger, and the forger was beside a painting.
- The forger may also be the murderer, but need not be; the victim is not the forger.
- Every row and every column holds exactly one person. As soon as you place someone, cross out their whole row and column.
- “Beside” = directly left, right, above or below, and in the same area. Squares with objects (paintings, tables, crates, the safe, the rostrum…) cannot be occupied; the chairs, the stools, the benches and the sofa can. A corner of an area is a square of that area that borders the outside (another area or the edge of the board) on one horizontal and one vertical side.
- “Right beside an area where nobody was” = on a square that touches an empty area directly – left, right, above or below, across the wall.
- Directions refer to rows and columns, not to the same line: “exactly one row north of him was a woman” = the person in the row directly above is a woman, in any column; “north of Augustin” = in a row further up, in any column.
- The murderer was alone with the victim: nobody else was in that area.
Statements
- Augustin (auctioneer’s assistant): Exactly five rows south of him was the forger. A woman was beside the same painting as him.
- Beatrix (cataloguer): She was in the Loading Bay. She and Dagny were on the same diagonal.
- Cyprian (porter): There were exactly two other people in his area. He and Norbert were on the same diagonal.
- Dagny (restorer): There was no bench in her area.
- Elspeth (cashier): A crate was somewhere in her row. She was beside a counter.
- Fenwick (shipping heir): Somebody else in his area was beside a chair. Somebody else in his area was beside the rostrum.
- Genevieve (retired judge): She was the only woman beside a chair.
- Humphrey (retired diplomat): There was a dealer in his area. The bookcase was somewhere in his row.
- Imelda (gallery owner’s widow): There was a dealer in her area. Somebody else was beside the same painting as her.
- Josiah (young tech millionaire): A cabinet was somewhere in his column.
- Kendra (Old Masters expert): There was no man in her area. She was not the forger.
- Lucian (Paris dealer): A desk was somewhere in his area. He was in the first row.
- Marguerite (provenance researcher): The cart was somewhere in her area. A crate was somewhere in her row.
- Norbert (art critic): He was beside a lamp. The forger was in his area.
- Odette (society columnist): She was right beside an area where nobody was. A bench was somewhere in her row.
- Vincent (the head auctioneer): The victim. Not the forger. He was found in the Strongroom, beside the safe – alone with the murderer.