Scenedoku

Crime-scene logic cases

The Auction House

Marlowe & Voss · opening night of the autumn sale · one of the guests is a forger · Difficulty: Chief 9 · 16×16

Opening night of the autumn sale at the Marlowe & Voss auction house. No sooner had the gavel fallen on lot 40 than a cry rang out from the Strongroom: Vincent, the head auctioneer, lay dead beside the safe. There are fifteen suspects – staff, collectors, dealers, members of the press. There was no time for lot 41.

Rules

  1. Of the fifteen suspects exactly one is the forger, and the forger was beside a painting.
  2. The forger may also be the murderer, but need not be; the victim is not the forger.
  3. Every row and every column holds exactly one person. As soon as you place someone, cross out their whole row and column.
  4. “Beside” = directly left, right, above or below, and in the same area. Squares with objects (paintings, tables, crates, the safe, the rostrum…) cannot be occupied; the chairs, the stools, the benches and the sofa can. A corner of an area is a square of that area that borders the outside (another area or the edge of the board) on one horizontal and one vertical side.
  5. “Right beside an area where nobody was” = on a square that touches an empty area directly – left, right, above or below, across the wall.
  6. Directions refer to rows and columns, not to the same line: “exactly one row north of him was a woman” = the person in the row directly above is a woman, in any column; “north of Augustin” = in a row further up, in any column.
  7. The murderer was alone with the victim: nobody else was in that area.

Statements

  • Augustin (auctioneer’s assistant): Exactly five rows south of him was the forger. A woman was beside the same painting as him.
  • Beatrix (cataloguer): She was in the Loading Bay. She and Dagny were on the same diagonal.
  • Cyprian (porter): There were exactly two other people in his area. He and Norbert were on the same diagonal.
  • Dagny (restorer): There was no bench in her area.
  • Elspeth (cashier): A crate was somewhere in her row. She was beside a counter.
  • Fenwick (shipping heir): Somebody else in his area was beside a chair. Somebody else in his area was beside the rostrum.
  • Genevieve (retired judge): She was the only woman beside a chair.
  • Humphrey (retired diplomat): There was a dealer in his area. The bookcase was somewhere in his row.
  • Imelda (gallery owner’s widow): There was a dealer in her area. Somebody else was beside the same painting as her.
  • Josiah (young tech millionaire): A cabinet was somewhere in his column.
  • Kendra (Old Masters expert): There was no man in her area. She was not the forger.
  • Lucian (Paris dealer): A desk was somewhere in his area. He was in the first row.
  • Marguerite (provenance researcher): The cart was somewhere in her area. A crate was somewhere in her row.
  • Norbert (art critic): He was beside a lamp. The forger was in his area.
  • Odette (society columnist): She was right beside an area where nobody was. A bench was somewhere in her row.
  • Vincent (the head auctioneer): The victim. Not the forger. He was found in the Strongroom, beside the safe – alone with the murderer.

← Cases