Scenedoku
Crime-scene logic cases
The Black-and-White Ball
Palazzo Zorzi-Grimani, Venice · the last night of Carnival, 1789 · a masked ball in black and white · Difficulty: Chief 10 · 16×16
Venice, carnival of 1789. Count Vincenzo Zorzi gives a black-and-white masked ball in his palace on the Grand Canal: every guest is dressed all in black or all in white, and on the chequered marble floor could stand only on a stone of their own colour. After midnight the count lay dead in the Library, beside his desk. Fifteen people were on the upper floor. The masks fell only later.
Rules
- The floor is a chequerboard of black and white marble (R1C1 is white, the colours alternate): whoever was dressed in black was on a black square, whoever was dressed in white on a white square.
- The colour of each person’s costume is shown on their card. Whoever was on a chair, a bench, a sofa, an armchair, the chaise longue or the bed counts as being on the square of that piece of furniture.
- Every row and every column holds exactly one person. As soon as you place someone, cross out their whole row and column.
- “Beside” = directly left, right, above or below, and in the same area. Squares with objects (pillars, tables, statues, candelabra, bookcases, the harpsichord…) cannot be occupied; the chairs, the benches, the armchairs, the sofas, the chaise longue and the bed can. An armchair is not a chair. A corner of an area is a square of that area that borders the outside (another area or the edge of the board) on one horizontal and one vertical side.
- Directions refer to rows and columns, not to the same line: “exactly one row north of him was a woman” = the person in the row directly above is a woman, in any column; “north of Jacopo” = in a row further up, in any column.
- The murderer was alone with the victim: nobody else was in that area.
Statements
- Amedeo (the Count’s brother): There was another man in his area. A bench was somewhere in his row.
- Benedetta (the Countess): She was alone with a guest. She was in the Ballroom.
- Cosima (the Count’s daughter): She and Marietta were on the same diagonal. A chair was somewhere in her area.
- Domenico (the Count’s nephew): He was in the Supper Room.
- Elettra (soprano): She was the only woman beside a candelabrum.
- Filiberto (French envoy): A card table was somewhere in his area. He was alone in his area.
- Ginevra (poetess): She was beside the lantern. She was beside a bench that nobody was sitting on.
- Hannibal (English traveller): He was the only man beside a candelabrum.
- Ilaria (miniature painter): Exactly one row north of her was a man.
- Jacopo (banker): A bookcase was somewhere in his row.
- Katharina (Austrian countess): A pillar was somewhere in her row. There was exactly one other person in her area.
- Lorenzo (majordomo): He was in a corner of his area. He was alone in his area.
- Marietta (lady’s maid): The chest was somewhere in her area. She was not in a corner of her area.
- Nazario (violinist): He was the only man sitting in a chair. He was alone with a woman.
- Orsola (cook): The counter was somewhere in her area. A chair was somewhere in her column.
- Vincenzo (the Count, the host): The victim. He was found in the Library, beside the desk – alone with the murderer.